Home Up Contents Search

Havre Job Service Employers' Committee                                        Employer Resource Guide                            

 

 

Suspect Questions

The following questions are often asked during interviews.  Although many of the questions may appear to be job-related, they all could provide information that could be used in discriminatory manner.  The potential problems with these questions are described following each question.

  1. What is your maiden name?  The question may indicate marital status, ethnicity or nation origin.  It cannot be used equally with males and females.
  1. What is your birthplace?  The answer may indicate race/ethnicity, national origin.  There is no job-related reason to know this information.
  1. What year  were you granted a high school diploma or GED?  The answer may indicate the age of the applicant.
  1. Are you a U.S. citizen?  The answer may indicate race/ethnicity.  Information on citizenship or work permits is required only after hire.
  1. What is the name and relationship of a person to contact in case of emergency?  This response may indicate marital status or national origin and is only necessary after hire.
  1. Please describe your health?  The answer may indicate disability status.
  1. What foreign languages do you speak?  How did you acquire this language facility?  The answer may indicate nation origin or race.
  1. Please list the date and circumstances of any arrests other than traffic violations?  Information about arrests may adversely affect minorities who are arrested at a higher rate than whites.  Arrests do not indicate whether the applicant was ever found guilty in a court of law.
  1. Are you willing to submit to a polygraph examination?  Montana law prohibits the use of all such tests in employment decisions (39-2-304 MCA).
  1. Please list all paid work experiences?  This leaves out voluntary work experience, which could adversely affect women.
  1. What is the lowest salary you would accept?  Employers cannot pay below federal minimum wage guidelines or equal pay laws.  Women typically put down lower salary expectations than men.
  1. Do you own a car you can depend on to get to work?  The response may indicate disability, alcohol-related problems or marital status.  Focus on the person’s ability to arrive to work on time.
  1.  Provide the names of three character references other than former employers or relatives?  The names may indicate ethnicity, national origin, and political or religious beliefs.
  1. Do you belong to the National Guard or reserve branch of the Armed Forces?  Montana law prohibits discrimination in employment based on membership in the “militia” (10-1-603 MCA).
  1. List organizations you belong to?  The answer may indicate religious/political/ethnic beliefs.
  1. Have you received workers’ compensation for a previous injury or illness?  This answer may indicate existence of a disability.
  1. Spouse’s occupation?  The answer may indication marital status.
  1. Do you own your home? Rent?  The answer may indicate marital status.
  1. What is the date and type of military discharge you received?  The response may indicate disability.  The question should be used only to administer veterans’ employment preference.
  1. Are you willing to take a physical exam?  This may indicate disability status.  Physical exams may only be required after a job offer as a condition for keeping the job.
  1. Do you use drugs?  The answer may indicate a disability status if applicant is using prescription drugs.  The question should be used only if there is a safety-related job concern.
  1. Are you willing to join a union?  The response may indicate religious beliefs.  Some religions forbid membership in such organizations.
  1. Are you a student?  The answer may indicate age.
  1. What arrangements have you made for the care of your dependant children?  The answer may indicate marital status.
  1. Please indicate if your spouse is employed by this company?  This answer indicates marital status.

 

LAWFUL & UNLAWFUL INTERVIEW QUESTIONS

This list is not exhaustive, it is meant to be a guide for formulating lawful pre-employment inquiries.

Age

         Unlawful:

How old are you?

What is your date of birth?

May I see your birth certificate or baptismal record?

         Lawful:

Are you 18 years of age or older?

Are you between the ages of 18 and 70 years?

 AIDS

           Unlawful:

Will you take an HIV test as a condition of employment?

Have you ever been tested for HIV? What was the result?

Lawful:

If being HIV free is a bona fide occupational qualification, the least intrusive question possible may be asked.

Arrest/Conviction Record

         Unlawful:

Have you ever been arrested?

Lawful:

If there is a direct relationship between the offense and the job or if hiring a person who has been convicted of a specific crime would be an unreasonable risk the employer may ask:

Have you ever been convicted of a crime?

If so, when, where and what was the nature of the crime?

Are there any felony charges pending against you?

Marital Status

         Unlawful:

Do you wish to be addressed as Ms., Mrs. or Miss?

Are you married, separated, divorced, widowed or single?

Have you ever been married?

Have you ever been divorced?       

What is your spouse’s name?

Where is your spouse employed?

What is your spouse’s income?

Do you have children?

How old are your children?

With whom do you reside?

        Lawful:

            Do you have any commitments that might hinder your attendance at work?

            Can you work the day (or night) shift?  

Sex

         Unlawful:

Male or female?

Are you pregnant?

Are you planning on having children or more children?

Do you use birth control?

Any inquiry made of only males or females.

    Lawful:

If there is a bona fide occupational qualification, an employer may ask male or female; for example, an opening for an attendant in a male-only locker room.

Sexual Orientation

            Unlawful:

  What is your sexual or affectional preference?

  Are you homosexual, transsexual, lesbian or bisexual?

  Are you gay?

Lawful:

None.

Medical Condition/Disability

             Unlawful:

Do you have any disabilities?

How severe is your disability?

What is the nature of your disability?

Have you collected workers’ compensation for a previous illness or injury?

How is your health?

Do you have any preexisting illnesses?

Have you ever had a mental or emotional breakdown?

Have you ever been hospitalized for a mental or emotional condition?

How many days were you absent because of illness last year?

Are you an alcoholic?

Lawful:

Can you perform the essential functions of the position you are applying for, with or without reasonable accommodation?

Use of Lawful Products

             Unlawful:

Do you smoke?

Do you use tobacco products? Do you drink?

Lawful:

A statement as to [Organization Name's) workplace smoking and drinking policies.

Race

Unlawful:

What is your race?

Black, Caucasian, Native American, Oriental?

What race are your parents? Children? Spouse?

With which racial group are you most closely aligned?

Do you have sickle cell trait?

How tall are you?

What color is your hair? Eyes? Skin?

Lawful:

None. Race or color is never a bona fide occupational qualification.

Religion

             Unlawful:

What religion are you?

Do you go to church?

For what religious holidays will you be unavailable to work?

May I see your birth certificate or baptismal certificate?

Is there a clergy person who would recommend your being hired?

Does your religion prevent you from working weekends or holidays?

Who is your pastor?

Lawful:

None. The interviewer may state what the employer’s work schedule is and, if the applicant has a concern or conflict. He or she may, but need not, comment on his or her availability.

Personal Appearance

Unlawful:

How tall are you?

How much do you weigh?

Do you have a current photograph?

What color are your eyes? Hair?

Do you have any scars? 

Do you have a tattoo?

             Lawful:

After being offered a job, can you provide me with a current photograph?

National Origin/Ancestry

             Unlawful:

Where were you born?

May I see your birth certificate or baptismal certificate?

Where were your parents (grandparents) born?

What is your first language?

How did you learn to read, write or speak (foreign language)?

What language do you speak at home?

What nationality are you? Your spouse? Your parents?

Lawful:

None.

Military Service

             Unlawful:

Have you served in the military?

What type of military discharge did you receive?

Have you ever served in the military of a foreign country?

Are you in the reserves?

Do you have any military obligations?

Were you ever disciplined while in the service?

Lawful:

Have you served in the United States Armed Forces (when service in the United States Armed Forces is a qualification for the job).

Citizenship

             Unlawful:

Are you a naturalized or native-born citizen?

When did you become a citizen?

Are you parents’ citizens?

May I see your naturalization papers?

Do you intend to become an American citizen? When?

             Lawful:

             After hiring you can ask:

      Are you a United States citizen?

Are you legally permitted to work in the United States?

 Financial Information

Unlawful:

Have you ever declared bankruptcy?

Has your pay ever been garnished?  

Are you obligated to pay child support?

Are you receiving public assistance?

Do you rent or own your home?

Do you own a car?

             Lawful:

             None. These questions tend to discriminate against individuals with lower incomes.

 

 

Home Up Contents Search

Send mail to havrejsc@mt.gov with questions or comments about this web site.
Last modified: January 30, 2008                                                                             Web Hosting Donated by Montana In Touch www.mtintouch.net